Shutup!'s Topics (471)

I think there was misunderstanding in her "novel POV". Maybe same like "The perks of being villain" MC who misunderstood the families hating on her while they were just being awkward.
From what I gather so far:
1. MC was never been harassed or abused by Perdia family
2. The duchess didn't fond of her (like of course it's normal when she brought in as illegitimate daughter) but duchess didn't even scold her or abusing her. She also react normally when MC visited her green house, she didn't even react hateful. Just normal but distant.
3. MC asked for engagement with 1st prince, while the duke against it at first, she was so stubborn, even the duke made the engagement happened.
4. Before MC got her previous live memories, she was allowed to spend money (MC clothes are good and pretty) and she said she harassed the maids, and only got scolding or probation from the duke. So it was clear that even if she act badly (typical brat villain) the family didn't really care. They don't even use her misbehaviour to slap her, or anything abusive.
5. Maybe term : they don't care. Is more fitting than abuse. It may not be complete neglect, but still "they don't care".
6. She lives separately in annex but it wasn't shabby building. She also allowed to eat in dining room together. And when she eat alone, she eat normal food not bad food like we always see in usual illegitimate story. She still have her tea time and even allowed to call designer to the house instead shopping to the shop.
7. Even tho she is illegitimate, the family still made her attending parties and balls as Perdia
8. About how the two brothers did, I think it was normal. Again, who will be happy if your father suddenly bring illegitimate child into home. But it's not like the brothers hit her or play prank on her.

I m guessing that her being killed in novel was not the doing of perdia family, but by some scheme of 2nd prince.

Lol, MC real power is bringing good luck to everyone she loves or care about (I strongly think so). My hypothesis is, it's not necessarily for her to stay with them, as long as she cares for them or wish something good for them, it will eventually happened one way or another. MC didn't lives with Mary the maid, but she got lucky with gold coin when MC wish Mary found gold coin. She also asked her ex fiance to pick up sword, and then he found his swordsmanship.
Also, the family started falling apart when MC no longer loves them. Lol.

It's the parents fault tho. They thought Diana was bringing good luck and severely neglected MC. Parents are humans so I understand they want to idolize the kid who they thought bringing good luck, but it soooo unnecessary for them to be cruel to MC. Let say they want to spoil Diana, then so be it. What it is for them to teach the other children to be disrespectful to their elder sister? To feel ashamed just because she "wasn't useful".

I hope the blonde girl is someone powerful who will help MC kick Leroy family lol

Wow so unbelievably stupid. Every single person told her that bitch is suspicious but MC was fawning over her. She even believed "Christina" is bad person, she has Christina memory, she was yes annoying and haughty, but not evil. Yet she believe that lie. So dumb

Kinda sad the artist downgraded Blan handsomeness. He was totally hot as proxy in the wedding. But now his design totally downgraded.
Btw, it's alright, MC & ML get together early on. They also don't have weird frustrating misunderstanding. Before the hunting festival with eastern noble, MC & ML will be rich (so it will be less than 2 months).

Let see. Both MC & ML are cute. They started off smart, come from good and harmonious family. ML definitely green flag with no misunderstanding whatsoever. They started dating early on.

But I m brothered by how inconsistent MC character is & not well built world.
Let start with,
At first MC found a book/novel that indicates she is living inside a book, but weirdly enough, everyone can read the book, and it's weird how robina accept it easily what written in the book and believe she is the FL of this world. While ML suddenly realized MC was from another world.
MC & ML knew Robina shenanigans, but MC let her get away with everything with "this is between robina and me, I'll deal with it myself". This is why I said MC is inconsistent, she is smart enough to know robina is not good person from the start, but she ALWAYS wanted to be friends with her, " If she doesn't act and be true to herself, I think I can be friends with her". It's so strange how MC knew Robina is manipulated real Viola and turned her into victim, but MC still "hope Robina doesn't stoop that low". Tbh, aside from lovey dovey part, I don't like how MC think.
And what's with her going to town without guards??
And she kept being annoying in front of " Wish Painting"

At first I was frustrated over ML personality. But I m glad after MC family learned that ML was actually just placeholder successor and being abused since young, MC family accept him and told him to think of them as family. They also offer ML to stay at their mansion instead of duke mansion. Ilya also provided ML with successor lesson, MC mother provided ML with swordsmanship lesson.
ML actually never learned swordsmanship, he was just just sent to battle since 14yo and only fight to survive. ML is kind hearted since childhood and very genius and also polite. Showered with love by MC family, ML finally found his own family who love him regardless. Made him no longer beg love from the duchy. He also never forgave his mother when she asked. Because he said, her love no longer important to him, because he already have family who believe in him and love him, regardless all the rumors and even support him. At least, he stopped being such a pushover begging for love.

Background story :
Duke was not initial successor as he was a 2nd son, so he didn't learn successor lesson, and he also lived his life freely also had a lover. But his older brother suddenly died from illness forced him to be a new successor. As a new duke, he had arranged marriage with the duchess (woman he didn't love). He performed his duty to have an heir (ML older brother). So he told his wife he will never love her and as they already have a son, he will never sleep with her again. One time, duke was drunk and slept with the duchess, mistook her as his lover. Duchess became pregnant and ML was born. Duke wasn't abusive to ML but everytime he sees ML he saw his own mistake, so he ignored him. He knew all the abuse, but he didn't care. And he was very much useless duke. The duchy was controlled by elders because duke is stupid.
Blair (ML older brother) has violence tendency. At a time, he realized ML was a genius. So he started blaming all his violence behavior as MLs. He killed ML pet bird, trashing the mansion, stole duches jewelry. And the duchess believed Blair was innocent sweet kind child while ML was irredeemable violent kid. Actually the maids and servants knew about it but they all kept quiet because Blair threatened to kill them if they tell the duchess. Even tho the duke dislike ML because he reminded him of his mistake, duke also terrible father to Blair, as he didn't see Blair was worthy successor. After Duke saw potential in ML, he supported ML as successor, Blair was enraged and killed the duke instantly, the duchess saw it. So she told lie that she will support Blair as successor. Duchess finally questioning all things that happened. She asked Blair that how he was a sweet child who bought flowers from florist and left it on her window. Blair immediately said yes he was. Duchess finally realized it was a lie. Because the flowers are wild flowers that left in front of her bedroom door. She also asked ex servants who worked around the time her children was kid, and they told her Blair was all the culprit but he threatened them. She regretted that she pushed away her sweet child and abused him for years only to keep the violent one around.
After the successor voting, Duchess voted for ML and also reported to elder that Blair was the one who killed the duke. She apologized to ML but ML told her, if she apologized after he return from war the 1st time (where ML bought music box), he will forgive her. But now her apologies and love are meaningless as he already found family and people who love him and see him as he is. Duchess left the capital and back to her own family home. She didn't attend her husband funeral or ML wedding. She works as managing the household, and send her salary to ML to cover the loan she took for Blair.

Yeah I like this tho. MC and her healthy family are such MVP. They helped ML a lot and genuinely like him

So many bad adults. Wtf. The only sane adult is the dad and I think the father is alright too, but father only concern about Leni. Oh adults in the duchy are also normal.

On the spoiler I read, the dad has been brainwashed by high priest since young to not love other than god (I think so he can hold papa tremendous holy power to himself), he kept saying, something terrible will happen to anyone papa loves aside from god. And papa believed it because the mom was cursed and died. So he was afraid asha will die if he loves her.
In all previous lives, papa always sent to subjugate monsters, so he always came late after asha died. Everytime asha died, he will massacre everyone and kill himself.
The mom was still alived but under cursed. Her body was preserved by Lux. Mom soul was the one calling asha so she repeated her lives all over. Asha mission from lux is to bring back mom to kingdom.
Mom will be the queen so asha can still lives as a princess. Papa will receive archduke title and recognized as asha father.
Asha will also run away with translator to gain power to take over the throne. Like she will run away for years to accumulate power, people support and money.

But I still can't bring myself to like papa. He did the deeds with princess Beatrice and then neglected his child. Yes yes brainwash brainwash. If brainwashing was that great, then why did he love princess Beatrice?? And they have been together since they were young. Then suddenly after asha born, oh yeah, the brainwashing works, I shouldn't love anyone aside from god. Geeezzz. I understand if he afraid he could bring destruction to asha if he loves her. But he can stay by her side, like dude, be her knight?? Talk to her?? Be her friend?? Visit her sometimes? Inquire about her wellbeing? I know he can't afford to be her dad but he can act like human being in all those 9 lives but he chose not to. I still don't like him tho. Cry me a river. Whatever. Asha gave him so many changes so they can be close together but he chose to distant himself. So annoying.

The story is so wholesome, she get along with everyone and all her cousins, even her jerk uncle turn softer. Love the familial love!

13yo evan is so cute, the way he is so sure how the baby is made is by holding hand, at night time, in bed, by married couple. He even smug about it "she is 14 but she doesn't even know how the baby is made" This is so cute